This Prohibition-era cocktail gets its name from a 1924 contest organized by a prohibitionist to invent a name for lawless drinkers, “to stab awake the conscience.”

We find no reports of conscience stabbings, but a bartender at Harry’s Bar in Paris thought the winning word — scofflaw — sounded like a fun name for a cocktail. This whiskey-vermouth sidecar-like cocktail was the result. 

The recipe has varied over time, with some bartenders preferring lemon, others lime. The exact proportions vary too — and you might prefer yours with a full two ounces of rye rather than one and a half. Regardless of the specifics, this is a strong, nicely dry, somewhat fruity cocktail that's delicious with rye or bourbon.

Ingredients

Tools

Jigger
Shaker
Strainer
Coupe or Nick and Nora Glass

Steps

  1. Measure rye, vermouth, Proof Syrup, citrus juice, and bitters into shaker; add ice and shake until well chilled and combined.
  2. Strain into chilled cocktail glass.
  3. Garnish with orange twist.

What You’ll Need

Shop All Products